November 2026 · Richard Maddrell
Why we don't score culture
Most culture surveys end with a number. A legal philosopher explains why the things that make work worth doing can’t be added up, and what to do instead.
Most culture surveys end with a number. Engagement at 72 per cent. Wellbeing up four points on last year. It's reassuring to have a number. You can put it on a slide, set a target and watch it move.
I've never met a team whose real difficulties were explained by its score, though. The number tells you that something is happening. It almost never tells you what, or why, or what it's costing the people inside it.
The trouble with a single number
A score quietly assumes that everything that matters at work can be added up on one scale. On that view, trust lost in one corner can be bought back with a pay rise in another, or a better office, or a team away day. Meaning, friendship and fairness all become units of the same currency, and the job is to push the total up.
That isn't how people experience work, and it isn't how organisations go wrong.
An idea from John Finnis
John Finnis is an Oxford legal philosopher. In his 1980 book Natural Law and Natural Rights he asked an old question: what makes a human life go well? His answer was a short list of what he called basic goods. These are things we recognise as worth having for their own sake, not because they get us something else. They include life and health, knowledge, play, the appreciation of beauty, friendship, the ability to think for ourselves and shape our own choices, and the search for meaning.
The part that matters most here is what he said about how these goods relate to each other. They are incommensurable. There's no common currency between them and no master good that the others serve. You can't pay for friendship with knowledge, and you can't make up for meaningless work with extra efficiency. Each one has to be honoured on its own terms.
Finnis also warned against letting efficiency run everything. Weighing up costs and outcomes has its place, but a life, or a community, organised only around the numbers will end up trading away the very things that made it worth having.
What this means for a workplace
A workplace is where many of us spend most of our waking hours, either pursuing these goods or being kept from them. Good work done well. Colleagues who become friends. Room to think and to have a say. A sense that what we do matters.
When a culture goes wrong, it usually isn't because a total has dropped. It's because one good has been traded for another, often without anyone deciding to. Speed is bought with people's voice. Targets are met at the cost of honesty. Growth comes at the price of meaning. A score hides these trades, while a good conversation brings them out.
How the Culture Audit works instead
That's why the Vitalis Culture Audit goes for depth rather than breadth, and why it rests on a well-chosen question rather than a survey or a scoring tool. We look at an organisation through five lenses:
Voice – whether people can say what they really think, and whether it makes a difference when they do.
Visibility – whether people, and the work they do, are actually seen.
Values – whether what the organisation says it cares about matches how it behaves.
Vitality – whether there's energy, health and life in the place.
Vulnerability – whether people can be honest about what's hard without having to protect themselves.
None of these is scored, and none can be swapped for another. A team with plenty of vitality and no voice isn't doing “quite well on average”. It has a specific problem that deserves a specific conversation.
The question, not the number
The goods that make work worth doing can't be put on one scale, and we don't pretend they can. What we can do is help an organisation see clearly which goods it's honouring and which it's quietly trading away, and then help it make room for them all.
That starts with listening, not counting.
Richard Maddrell – November 2026
Keep reading
October 2026
Building Connection - What Marketing Is Made For
Connecting the right person, the right product or service, the right place. That’s what marketing is for.
September 2026
Marketing: A Wonderful Tool That Has Too Often Been Badly Used
Marketing is one of the most powerful tools we have for shaping how people see themselves and the world — and it has too often been pointed at their frailties rather than their flourishing.
Recognise your own organisation in this?
The first conversation is free, and there is no obligation to go further.
Book a free conversation